In this episode, Kirstin and Bey are talking all about the marriage. Historian Dr. Rebecca Davis shares about her research in how the institution of marriage has changed over the years. Later on the episode, Dr. Das shares her research on how mammals create relationships with one another.
Links for this episode:
- Learn more about Dr. Rebecca Davis
- Learn more about Dr. Jayatri Das
- Read a transcript of this episode
Transcript
Hello, friends, and welcome to So Curious, presented by the Franklin Institute.
Speaker:We are your hosts- I am the Bul Bey.
Speaker:And I am Kirstin Michelle Cills.
Speaker:Bey and I are so stoked to bring you this
Speaker:season all about the science behind love, sex, and relationships.
Speaker:So far, we've talked about everything from
Speaker:your brain on love, to why we obsess over our favorite television characters to how
Speaker:science and tech are changing our relationships with each other.
Speaker:Okay, so all season we've been talking
Speaker:about science and all different aspects of relationships.
Speaker:I think it's time to tackle the elephant in the room... Marriage.
Speaker:The ring on the finger.
Speaker:In this episode, we are talking to historian Dr.
Speaker:Rebecca Davis about how the institution of
Speaker:marriage, as we know it actually came to be.
Speaker:And later, Dr.
Speaker:Jayatri Das will be back to talk to us
Speaker:about what the science world is saying about marriage.
Speaker:Okay, so do you want to get married now?
Speaker:This is so sudden.
Speaker:We work together, be professional.
Speaker:I'm sorry.
Speaker:I don't really know what I think about marriage.
Speaker:Both my parents have been married three times.
Speaker:I definitely think that marriage is great if you find the right person.
Speaker:I also think that there's a lot of room in the world for marriage to not necessarily
Speaker:be to one person for the rest of your life.
Speaker:It often isn't that way, whether that was by design or by things not working out.
Speaker:I sound like a downer.
Speaker:No.
Speaker:I'm going to be Kirsten's translator- nah- it's a no for me.
Speaker:Not for me dog. Yeah.
Speaker:No.
Speaker:But it was definitely interesting to understand and know that all the things
Speaker:that we don't talk about, what we know, people get married for status, resource,
Speaker:all these different things have always been at play.
Speaker:So it's nice to know that we weren't crazy and we haven't been crazy.
Speaker:But it's also nice to know we're all considering different things.
Speaker:I don't think I'm getting married for money or titles or anything like that.
Speaker:And it's nice to rethink and assess these things personally, individually.
Speaker:Yeah, there are definitely benefits to
Speaker:marriage in many ways, but also there's a lot of societal pressure.
Speaker:Also, a lot of people get married because they're like, well, all my friends are,
Speaker:and I don't do it now, when am I going to do it right?
Speaker:And it's nice to have historical context to even project into the future.
Speaker:It's like, what is marriage going to look like 50 years from now?
Speaker:Because these behaviors are going to change and that's going to change how we
Speaker:interact with our environment in so many different ways.
Speaker:All these different things were really
Speaker:interesting to kind of, like, delve into and navigate.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And our first guest is a true actual expert on marriage.
Speaker:So let's introduce our first guest, marriage historian Dr.
Speaker:Rebecca Davis.
Speaker:Thank you so much for having me on the podcast.
Speaker:One of the books that you have here in the
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:02
the American Search for Marital Bliss".
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:06
Tell us about the findings in the book,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:07
your research, and reflect on that book a little bit.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:10
This is a book about how self styled experts of various kinds taught Americans
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:16
how to be husbands and wives in the 20th century.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:19
And they did that very often through what we know as marriage counseling.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:23
And marriage counseling could be something that's called marital counseling or
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:28
couples counseling, but it was very often less formal than that.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:32
It was ministers and rabbis meeting with couples in the weeks leading up to their
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:37
marriages or meeting with them in crisis counseling afterward.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:41
It was social workers at family service agencies, and it was professional
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:46
psychologists and psychiatrists in other formats.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:48
And it really takes off in the United
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:50
States in the 1930s, and of course, it's still around today.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:03:55
So what I found in the book was a surprising concern with heterosexuality.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:01
I wanted to know what ministers and rabbis who were starting to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:06
get more and more open to psychology ministers and rabbis said, we need to get
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:11
a little bit more savvy about how to give counseling.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:14
And so they started to read up on social science and psychology.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:18
They formed journals and societies, and they started to introduce psychology
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:23
classes into their seminaries to train rabbis and ministers.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:27
And so I was really interested, well, what did they think about homosexuality?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:32
Because in the 1930s, 1940s, 1950s,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:36
professional psychology was starting to define homosexuality as a mental illness.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:41
And that was all sort of happening then.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:44
The shift from seeing same sex desire as either just an aberration or more
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:49
negatively, as a sin was becoming more defined as a psychological problem.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:55
What happens by the period that I was
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:04:59
starting to look at in the was a fear that there was latent homosexuality present and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:07
that that was explaining people's levels of dissatisfaction with their lives.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:11
So what I found I was looking through the indexes of these journals.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:14
This is the nuts and bolts of historical research.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:17
It's not a Google search.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:18
It's hours and hours in dusty libraries,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:22
pulling journals off the shelf, looking at the index, all of the articles in these
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:27
journals where clergy are trying to learn how to be psychologically more astute
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:32
homosexuality is mentioned in articles about marriage, why on earth were they
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:37
talking about homosexuality in the context of marriage?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:40
This is obviously decades and decades
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:42
before any sort of national debate over same sex marriage.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:45
And that was not what they were talking about.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:48
They were worried about a sort of psychoanalytic idea of the latent
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:05:54
homosexual, that children have a sort of innate
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:02
bisexuality, but you're supposed to mature into heterosexuality.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:12
And so adult maturity and heterosexuality go together.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:16
This was like understood science of that.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:18
This was understood mental health sort of baseline of the time.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:23
And so that homosexuality then means that
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:27
a person hasn't fully psychologically matured.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:30
Their psychosexual development has been,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:32
quote unquote, arrested in an adolescent or stage.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:39
You are blowing my mind right now.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:41
So then if you say, okay, why is this woman hesitant about marriage?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:45
Or why is she really dissatisfied with her marriage?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:49
Maybe she has latent lesbian tendencies as they would talk about it.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:54
So one of the things that has changed
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:06:57
that's in the background of all of this is that it's become easier to get divorced.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:01
I remember seeing something online, I don't know the exact date that they were
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:04
saying, but it was like when people say people who are maybe like elderly now
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:11
well, in my day people didn't get divorced like this.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:13
It's like, well, women weren't allowed to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:14
have their own bank accounts until 1970 something.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:18
Is that correct? That's correct, yeah.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:20
And so it's like it really has nothing to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:22
do with people being less happy with each other.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:24
It's just a matter of logistics.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:26
So one of the other things though, that's happened is that this idea that "you're
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:29
supposed to be happy in your marriage" had to come along first.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:33
So that is also changing.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:35
And so the idea that marriage is about romance, that marriage is a choice that
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:40
two people make and that they should expect a certain level of happiness and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:44
companionship has been around for about 300 years in any sort of broad way.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:49
That doesn't mean that there weren't
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:51
couples thousands of years ago who loved one another.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:54
But the broader purposes of marriage were not mutual compatibility and emotional
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:07:59
satisfaction, let alone sexual satisfaction.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:02
That's far more recent.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:04
That's also when you have easier divorce options.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:08
You have women's increasing economic
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:11
independence, and then you have all these experts saying, "oh wow, we've got to find
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:16
a way to keep these people together" and there you have marriage counseling.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:22
Good point.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:23
If making the decision about marriage is not financial anymore, what would you say
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:27
are some of the main factors that you see people are getting married?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:30
Why are people getting married in 2022?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:32
I think marriage still is an economic strategy for a lot of people.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:36
I was just listening to a radio story, I
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:39
think yesterday about what the student loan repayment reprieve has meant for
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:44
people in their twenty's and their thirties over the last 18 months or two
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:48
years or however long it's been and I think that we can't underestimate the
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:52
degree to which pooling resources remains a strategy for a lot of people.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:08:57
The acceptance around cohabitation though,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:00
is completely different now than it was in years past.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:04
This idea that you and a person you're
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:06
affectionately bound to, someone you love, to put it simply, could live together.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:10
I like "affectionately bound to".
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:12
Yeah because sometimes these relationships are sexual, sometimes they're not.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:16
But this idea of setting up house with someone because you want to live with them
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:21
and make a home with them, I think that's still very appealing to a lot of people.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:24
I think it's still an economic strategy.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:26
There was always jokes when I was living in New York City in my early twenties, and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:30
there was always this joke that people moved in together so quickly because rent
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:34
was so high, and it was like you couldn't afford an apartment on your own.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:37
I think this idea of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:41
building a lasting relationship with a particular individual that will bring you
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:46
all kinds of community and satisfaction, I think that remains very appealing but
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:50
we have a legal structure that still privileges marriage.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:54
Makes it so much easier in so many ways.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:09:57
If you want to have certain parental rights and if you want to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:02
have certain understandings when you pay your taxes with Social Security- there are
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:08
all kinds of ways in which marriage remains economically beneficial
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:12
and just sort of legally simplifies a lot of stuff.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:16
If you want to be recognized as somebody's
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:18
person, it's much easier to do that if you're legally married to them.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:23
Yeah.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:23
And so I know you serve as a producer and a story editor for a podcast.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:28
Could you tell us a little bit about that? Sure.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:30
The Sexing History podcast started in 2017, and it was an effort by a group of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:38
historians of sexuality to take some of the audio archives of this history and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:46
bring them to a wider audience and to tell stories that we don't otherwise hear and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:51
to show in many ways how this history is still relevant.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:54
Wonderful.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:54
Yeah, I definitely got to take a listen to that.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:57
What do you hope your students take away
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:10:59
from your teachings and your findings and research?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:01
One of my very favorite classes to teach is an introductory survey course called
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:07
American Sexualities, and I'm happy to say its a very popular course.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:12
I had 165 plus students take it online the last time I taught it.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:19
And what I teach in that course is that, all of these things have a history.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:24
That the things we might think about, but when people talk about what's natural or
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:29
traditional, that doesn't really mean anything to a historian.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:33
Historians don't talk about, you know, whether we've lost a tradition.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:39
We see all these things as ever changing.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:42
So what I hope my students take away from it is
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:45
I hope that the next time they hear someone talking about, well, that's not
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:49
natural or that's not traditional, they have the tools to stop and say, in fact, I
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:11:54
think I understand that's an a historical way to think about that question.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:00
I hope my students, particularly a lot of my students, are
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:04
themselves in the process of coming out, or they're transitioning, or they have
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:10
loved ones and family members who are LGBTQ plus, or
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:17
my students who have had abortions, my students who've had various experiences
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:21
with using different kinds of contraception.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:23
The students are in the room because
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:25
something very close to them relates to the topic of the course, and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:30
they're there to try to figure out, am I new?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:37
Is there a history to me or to my loved one or my friend?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:42
How do I fit in? Where is my story?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:45
Where is my history?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:46
What's the answer to some of those questions?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:48
Am I new? Where's my history?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:49
Where's my story? Yeah, I love those questions.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:52
And what I tell my students is this, that, for instance, with trans history, which is
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:12:58
really exciting, there's tons of new work being done in it right now.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:02
With trans history, I can talk to them about a person
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:07
who arrived in colonial Virginia around 1620, I believe it was 1627 or 1628.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:14
And this person
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:16
changed their name and their gender during the process of immigration,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:21
but also had previously had multiple gender identities prior to emigrating and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:28
fought as a soldier, but also worked as a seamstress and would wear the attire
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:33
appropriate and the hairstyle appropriate and the gender pronouns appropriate to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:38
those roles and was a domestic servant in a female social role in Virginia and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:47
got caught in bed with a maid, another indentured servant.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:50
And the question was, could fornication have occurred?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:53
Fornication in colonial Virginia meant sex outside of marriage?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:57
And that's especially for indentured
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:13:59
servants the landowners wanted to control their working population, and pregnancy
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:05
really affects the management of your household.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:08
Right.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:08
So, like, we're getting historical tea right now.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:10
Yes.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:12
So this person who goes by the name Thomas or Thomasine is brought before the court
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:17
and basically asked, "are you man or woman?" And Thomas Thomasine says, I am
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:22
both, and I have parts of both and refuses the question.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:27
And there are these invasive bodily
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:30
inspections of them by local women, which was a practice dating back to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:35
Middle Ages in Europe, that midwives and the local women would be called upon to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:42
provide evidence and allegations of impotence and other things like that.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:45
There are other people who decide it's up
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:48
to them to sort of pull up the pull off the bed sheets and inspect Thomas
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:53
Thomasine's body- and ultimately, the court rules that
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:14:59
this person must wear elements of both genders clothing.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:05
At the time there's no androgynous clothing in the 17th century.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:08
There's very much females and dresses and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:12
people understood as men in different breaches and other clothes.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:18
And then they kind of go about their life, and there's no other record of them.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:21
They're not jailed.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:22
They're not expelled from the colony.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:27
What an icon.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:28
Wow.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:32
I tell my students, so if you feel that your gender is nonbinary, if you feel that
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:38
you are trans, there are people in the past who also felt that.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:43
That said, they didn't have the word transgender.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:48
There was no sense of trans rights.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:50
There was no sense of a broader queerness that would have given someone
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:15:56
a man who desired sex with a man, would not have had any social framework, any
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:01
idea that he had anything in common with this non binary person.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:07
So I tell my students, I'm a little
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:08
hesitant to say there are transgender people throughout history.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:11
I'm absolutely comfortable saying there are people who lived outside the bounds of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:17
their time's gender norms throughout history.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:19
I would ask you, as a historian, how important is it to have these stories
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:24
documented, saved, shared, and disseminated?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:28
What's amazing is that the courts in
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:31
colonial Virginia, a lot of those records survived.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:35
Even in the case of Thomas Thomasine, there are places where the
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:40
document is so frayed or parts of it have ripped off that you lose part of it.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:45
There's a place where Thomas Thomasin describes their body, and we only have
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:49
part of what they said about how they understood their body.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:53
So that's a loss.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:16:54
But there's so much more now that you can get from these sources from 500 years ago
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:00
that have been digitized, and you can find them online.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:04
I'm curious. So you expressed to us off mic when you
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:09
first got here something that I found really interesting, which is that people
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:12
tend to ask you, how do I make a marriage work?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:16
Which is not your field at all. Right?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:17
You're on the historical side of marriage.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:20
Is there any research in what you've been doing about how people have answered that
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:25
question in the past and how it's changed over the course you've been looking over?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:30
One of the big theories around the mid 20th century was that the more alike you
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:34
are in every way except gender, the more likely you are to have a good marriage.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:39
So you want men to be manly and women to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:41
be feminine, but otherwise, same religion, same race and ethnicity better.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:47
That both.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:47
Either come from rural or both from suburban, you know, on and on and on.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:51
And so a whole host of people start to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:17:55
create tests and questionnaires that they give to engaged couples to see.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:02
Well, before you go to the altar, let's
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:04
double check that you have a chance of sort of longterm happiness.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:08
Wow.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:09
And psychologists had been working on personality tests by that point.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:15
The 1920s is sort of when the first intelligence tests are rolled out.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:18
And by the 1930s, they've taken some of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:21
those questions and others and created personality tests.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:25
And they also thought that they could
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:27
administer modified versions of these personality tests to engage people to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:32
figure out if their personalities were compatible.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:35
Is this science?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:36
Would you consider that science?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:38
They considered it science.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:39
Yeah. Nice answer.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:42
This is a great segue into our last question, which is, what can you tell us
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:47
about the very sought after narrative of finding a soulmate?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:53
Has there been research on that data history?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:56
Great question.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:57
Thank you.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:18:59
It was something that I tried to think about when I was writing More Perfect
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:03
Unions- this idea that marriage will bring you this ultimate happiness.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:07
And
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:10
it is both a motivating drive for a lot of people to go out and date and find
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:18
a partner, but it also becomes a source of a lot of disappointment and frustration.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:24
So I don't know what it's like today to be
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:28
going through that, but it becomes a source of dissatisfaction for a lot of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:32
people when they find out that people with the sort of cliche, the
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:36
honeymoon is over and they have to deal with life as it is.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:42
So this idea that there is someone who is a soulmate is probably I don't actually
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:49
know precisely, but I'm guessing it's an idea about 100 to 150 years old.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:53
In the 19th century and early 20th, we
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:19:56
have lots of examples of men writing passionately romantic letters to other men
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:01
and then getting married to women and vice versa.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:05
And we sort of have to guess about when
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:08
those passionate relationships were also erotic or in fact, realized as sexual.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:13
But what's totally obvious is that people found passionate intimacy from a variety
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:21
of people, not just their spouses, and that it was important to them that these
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:25
friendships were central to how they got through the day.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:30
So there are letters from two young men
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:33
from Michigan who served in the Civil War together.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:36
They went all the way with Sherman's Army down to Atlanta, and they wrote letters to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:41
one another where they referred to one as husband and wife.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:44
They talked about their
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:46
keeping warm together in the tent on the march, and they showed these letters to
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:50
their sisters, who would add postscripts because the families knew each other, so
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:55
there was no secrecy around this and then each young man got married.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:20:59
They continued to write letters, but they
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:01
said, well, maybe don't show your wife this one in some of them but
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:06
marriage was the way you went about for these men going to the Dakota Territory,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:12
getting some land, starting an adult life but their passionate relationship, their
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:18
greatest emotional intimacy, was with another man.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:22
So this much more 20th century idea and now 21st, that you have one person
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:31
with whom you're supposed to have your most intense sexual, emotional,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:37
coparenting or cohabiting relationship is all in one person.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:43
Is that's a lot?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:44
That's a lot.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:46
So I don't know if people are finding their soulmates more than they used to or
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:51
not, but this very notion is part of the way in which we've moved
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:21:58
our culture has been very negative toward kinship based models.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:03
The whole negative connotation around African American family
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:07
strategies that comes out from the 19th century into the debates over social
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:13
welfare programs in the 20th, that denigration of alternate family forms
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:19
happens at the same time that people are saying, no, it's just marriage.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:22
It's a man and a woman in one household raising their children.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:27
That's what a healthy household looks like.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:30
That's what happiness looks like.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:31
And that's where you find your soulmate is
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:33
through that rather than through broader networks of kin or a wider number of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:38
people with whom you have different kinds of intimacy.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:41
Incredible. Dr.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:42
Rebecca Davis, thank you for coming in.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:44
Thank you so much.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:45
It was a real pleasure.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:47
Thanks so much to Dr.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:48
Rebecca Davis.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:49
Now that we have an understanding of where
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:52
marriage came from, let's talk about cockroaches.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:55
I say we jump right into our next segment to debrief about the science side of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:22:59
marriage with chief bioscientist at the Franklin Institute, Dr.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:03
Jayatri Das.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:04
Or a segment we all know and love called Body of Knowledge.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:09
Hey, Jayatri. Hi, Kirsten.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:10
Hi, Bey. Hey, how are you?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:12
Good Good.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:13
This is a topic that I am fascinated by
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:16
because it's a place where the advancement of scientific technology has really
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:21
changed scientists perception of relationships in the animal world.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:27
So let me tell you a little bit what I mean.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:30
So before the advent of DNA fingerprinting, scientists thought that
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:35
there were lots of species that were monogamous for life.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:40
So if we think about what we perceive as marriage, as having lifelong relationships
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:44
with the same mate, people thought that there are lots of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:48
species that had that same kind of behavior.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:52
But then in the 1990s, we developed the
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:55
technology to do DNA fingerprinting- imagine a simple way is just think about
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:23:59
how paternity tests work in the courts, right?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:03
So imagine that we now have the technology
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:06
to do paternity tests not just for humans, but for any species.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:12
And suddenly we realize that all of these animals that we thought were getting
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:18
married, so to speak, or being monogamous throughout their life, we're not.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:25
We were fingerprinting their offspring and
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:28
realizing that females were mating with different males.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:31
So even if there's what we call pair
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:34
bonding between a male and a female that raise offspring together and spend time
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:40
together, they still occasionally mate with other animals outside of their bond.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:46
And so that really changed the perception
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:48
of what we think of as monogamy and marriage in the scientific world.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:53
And some scientists now are thinking that,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:24:55
well, maybe we had those assumptions beforehand because of our own bias of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:00
thinking about marriage from our human experience.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:06
I was going to say every cartoon loves to portray this happy husband and wife fish
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:13
in the sea looking for their son Nemo or whatever.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:17
And it's like, no, they probably have plenty of other people on the side.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:20
Right?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:22
Bunch of other fish. Yeah.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:24
So to put that into perspective, let's look at mammals first.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:29
If you look at any two individuals of a
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:32
monogamous species, they may have made it for life.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:34
But if you look at the entire species, not a single mammal species has been
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:39
definitively shown to be actually monogamous.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:43
So even if you look more broadly at thinking about social monogamy, where you
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:49
do kind of maybe hook up with other animals here and there.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:53
It's still only like three to 5% of all
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:25:57
the mammal species on Earth practice any form of monogamy.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:00
Wow. Damn.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:02
People aren't ready for that conversation, are they?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:06
Well, hopefully they're having that conversation.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:07
It's important to add.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:09
It's really important.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:10
Can you give me a few minutes to talk about cockroaches?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:17
As I was reading about this, this one species of cockroach just hooked me
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:23
because I'm so fascinated by how their mating systems work.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:27
And it's a species of a Japanese cockroach
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:31
that are one of the only species that have been found to be truly monogamous.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:38
And we know this because after they mate,
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:42
they eat each other's wings so that they are literally locked into where they live.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:50
Literally tied down.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:51
They are literally tied down because they can't leave.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:55
Oh, my gosh.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:56
Sounds like a toxic relationship to me. I don't don't know.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:26:59
They eat each other's wings.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:00
There's lots of examples where like, the
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:02
female might eat the male or things like that.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:04
But no, this is mutual.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:05
Yeah, because I was thinking about is it
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:07
grasshoppers that the female rips the head off of the map?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:10
I like praying mantises.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:13
Yeah, but this is a mutual understanding that they're both going to.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:18
That doesn't sound pleasant. And it's like, you know who goes first?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:22
We don't shame what anybody's into here.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:26
This Japanese researcher named Haruka Osaki discovered this and she videotaped
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:32
pairs of cockroaches and found out that they literally eat each other's wings.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:38
And it's probably beneficial for them
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:40
because they live in these really tight spaces.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:43
So once you've found your mate, you don't need to look anymore.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:47
So why not just get rid of your wings by eating them?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:50
And then you are a better fit for your
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:53
house and you don't need to go anywhere anymore.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:55
That resonates. Right?
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:56
Because once you're in a relationship, delete that tinder app.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:27:59
Delete all those other things, man, this is permanent.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:03
Yeah, but there are other examples of animals that practice some sort of
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:08
monogamy, like prairie or another example of a rodent that does this.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:12
So I wouldn't classify them too
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:15
specifically, but this particular behavior is really unique.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:18
Yeah, because I'm not biting anyone.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:23
Just not going to do that.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:25
Well, now that we've heard from the science world, we are going to take this
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:28
time to see what average people are thinking about as it relates to marriage.
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:32
For this segment, we are going to take to the Internet to see what the most popular
studio is "More Perfect Unions 00:28:37
Google searches are surrounding our episode topic.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Google Autofill.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:So we went into the old Google and typed
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:in "Is Marriage..?" And let Google fill the rest for us.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:So the first thing that came up was "is
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:marriage for me?" Question mark- maybe in like 30 to 40 years, right?
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Pairing and bonding and being with someone.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:We're still social animals.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:We're asking really good questions about
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:monogamy, really good questions about polyamory, but we're social, so
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:hopefully you'll be around someone or group of people into your golden years.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Maybe we learned a little bit about the history of marriage and how those social
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:pressures influence that kind of a decision.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:You know, there's some social pressures.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:There's always a grand mom around like, I want some kids.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:So the Googler Engine then told me, I just
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:wanted to know, "is there a marriage for me?
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:quiz- a lot of people wanted to know this, is there a marriage for Me quiz?
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:There probably is. I don't know.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:That's kind of interesting.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:I bet there are some correlations to personality traits and psychology that
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:predict whether someone is more likely to get married than somebody else.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Yeah. And there's like Love Language Quizzes and
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:everything where you can find better the way you want to be loved and all of that.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:But the way that this is phrased makes me
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:think someone's looking for a BuzzFeed quiz.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:It's like, tell me your coffee order and
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:I'll tell you if you're going to get married.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Ice grande. Yeah.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:What is it? Two pump.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:This is not I'm just making this up.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:You're not getting married.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Just give me a straight black coffee. That's all I want.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Okay. You're getting married.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Okay. So moving on.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:We put into the Google Engine, is marriage religious?
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Is marriage religious? Used to be, right?
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Probably. Yeah.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:And yet we have adopted it as a non religious custom.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:There's some definite interplay between how religious norms get integrated into
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:broader culture and how that may have evolved from some
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:sort of social benefit of long term monogamy.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:The church. Yeah, right.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Because it was at one point a religious
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:thing, and now you don't have to be religious.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:You can get married by anybody.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Not necessarily a clergy person. Right.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Yeah. Marriage is a mystery to me.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Certainly that pressure for marriage goes cross cultural.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Not necessarily one religion here.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Yeah. Right.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Somebody who's not coming from the Christian church.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Big thanks to Dr.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Davis, Dr.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Das, for joining us on this episode of So Curious.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:And next week will be our final episode of the season.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:And in true dramatic, theatrical fashion,
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:our final episode will be all about Ghosting.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Because when this season ends, isn't that really just Bey and I ghosting?
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:This and more on next week's episode.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:So please subscribe to this podcast wherever you listen to rate us.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Talk about how fun we are.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Talk about how great my voice is.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Talk about Bey.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Ask him to rap for you, all those things. Okay.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Yeah. Leave us some messages.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:We want to know how much you love this podcast.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Yeah. And I am the Bul Bey.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:And I am Kirsten michelle Cills and we will see you next week.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Bye bye.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:So Curious is presented by the Franklin Institute.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Special thanks to Franklin Institute producers Joy Montefusco and Dr.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Jayatri Das.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:This podcast is produced by Radio Kismet.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Radio Kismet is Philadelphia's premier podcast production studio.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:Head of operations is Christopher Plant.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:The managing producers Emily Charash the producers Lilianna Green.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:The lead audio engineer and editor is Christian Cederlund.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:The editors are Lauren DeLuca and Justin Berger.
So this is Body of Knowledge:
Speaker:The science writer is Kira Villette and the graphic designer is Emma Sager.
